Saturday, 27 February 2010

Un-Wiki'ed

I did it some days back and though I should be feeling happy about it, I am not. I am talking about Wikipedia. Last week I edited a page on it where I found a mistake and then I found some more mistakes on it and edited it more, even added some stuff. Now the very purpose of my visiting Wikipedia is reduced to finding mistakes on the page and correcting them. I want to get out of this obsession.

Moreover, this has shaken my belief in the authenticity of the content posted. Though I always knew that wiki pages were editable, I had never done it. Now that I have, it seems like there can be a lot of pages with plenty of mistakes. Moreover, a person can edit the existing content and make it look entirely different from what it initially intended to be. Wiki has the features of 'discussion' , 'edit' and 'citation needed', but I really doubt if majority of people pay attention to them.

Where to go in such a scenario?? Earlier whenever I came across a fact, I used to verify it from Wikipedia. Many times, it turned out the facts were lifted from Wikipedia itself. On one particular occasion when I wanted to counter check the fact, all the other sites quoted essentially the same content as on Wikipedia and gave its reference as well. What if the content on Wiki is wrong in first place?? Wikipedia authorities should come up with a solution where the content which is authentic and is not going to change in future can be made uneditable. For the rest I guess, people are doing a good job and modifying the content wherever and whenever necessary(for this I give myself a pat on my back...:) :P ;)).

4 comments:

  1. hmm.. helpful
    we are rather dependent on Wikipedia.

    But other online sources are tough and how does one authenticate their credibility? And then they ask for money :-)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Good when know and others do not.
    Take any bet with confidence and then modify the data accordingly before cross-verification.
    However, as a honest guy, change it later again to correct data :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. And yes, i read that "Fortis" hospital error you pointed in 3 idiots.
    I thought only i noticed it!!

    ReplyDelete
  4. he he...
    the best thing about wiki is the discussion thread... tried it at times of MAHABHARAT obsession, when we used to discuss mahabharat characters only in college. Got a lot of legends and there...

    ReplyDelete